Overview of this article:

Undetected thyroid problems have plagued people for years, and
continue to be an underlying cause for a variety of ailments that doctors
hear about today. The onset of hypothyroidism is often subtle, with
symptoms gradually worsening over time, becoming more obvious as
people age.

Hypothyroidism: Beyond Normal Temperature – A Comprehensive Summary

The traditional “normal” body temperature of 98.6°F, established from an 1860s study of 25,000 patients, may no longer accurately reflect optimal health. Recent research suggests the average body temperature has dropped to 98.2°F, potentially indicating a widespread increase in mild to moderate hypothyroidism. This shift challenges our understanding of what constitutes “normal” versus “optimal” health markers.

The Hidden Epidemic

Dr. Broda Barnes, author of “Hypothyroidism: The Unsuspected Illness,” identified subtle hypothyroidism as increasingly common throughout the 20th century. Dr. Alan Gaby suggests this apparent epidemic stems from multiple factors, including thyroid hormone resistance induced by environmental pollutants and evolutionary changes in our population. Historically, people with mild hypothyroidism often died from infections like pneumonia before diagnosis; modern antibiotics now allow these individuals to survive and reproduce, potentially propagating genetic tendencies toward hypothyroidism, particularly in women.

Understanding Thyroid Function

The thyroid gland produces two primary hormones: thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3). While T4 comprises 80% of thyroid production, T3 performs 90% of the actual metabolic work in the body. The thyroid operates within a complex regulatory system involving the pituitary gland, which produces thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH), and the hypothalamus, which controls the pituitary.

Critical to thyroid function is the conversion of T4 to the metabolically active T3, primarily occurring in the liver and kidneys. This conversion process is sensitive to various nutritional, hormonal, and environmental factors. Excesses of high-fat diets, estrogen, stress hormones like cortisol, and minerals like cadmium can impair conversion. Deficiencies in selenium, iodine, iron, zinc, riboflavin, and adequate protein also disrupt this crucial process.

Diagnostic Challenges

Standard thyroid diagnosis relies on blood tests measuring TSH, T4, and sometimes T3. However, these tests have significant limitations. The “normal” ranges may be too broad, missing mild to moderate cases. Thyroid hormone levels fluctuate throughout the day and are influenced by diet, lifestyle, and stress. Additionally, blood tests typically measure total hormone levels rather than the “free” or biochemically available portions that actually affect cellular function.

Dr. Kent Holtorf highlights another critical issue: tissue hormone levels can be severely low even when blood levels appear normal, suggesting problems with hormone transport into cells. Conditions like diabetes, migraines, depression, chronic fatigue, and inflammation can impair cellular energy, reducing the body’s ability to transport thyroid hormones effectively. Certain medications, including benzodiazepines like Valium and Xanax, can also interfere with T3 cellular uptake.

The Barnes Temperature Test

Dr. Barnes advocated for a simple basal temperature test as a more reliable indicator of thyroid function than standard blood tests. This approach recognizes that body temperature reflects metabolic rate and overall thyroid activity. While not perfect, the temperature test has proven valuable for detecting mild to moderate hypothyroidism that blood tests might miss.

Recognizing Symptoms

Hypothyroidism symptoms develop gradually and affect individuals differently, making diagnosis challenging. Common symptoms include excessive fatigue, cold sensitivity, irregular heartbeat, menstrual problems, weight difficulties, fluid retention, hair and skin changes, mental impairment including depression and poor concentration, reduced perspiration, resistant constipation, frequent infections, muscle weakness, and joint pain. Unfortunately, many healthcare providers don’t recognize these varied symptoms as potentially thyroid-related.

Related Health Conditions

Research reveals strong connections between hypothyroidism and various health issues. Menstrual disorders have long been associated with thyroid dysfunction, with early 20th-century gynecologists reporting that thyroid therapy cured more menstrual problems than all other treatments combined. Dr. Barnes successfully treated infertility and miscarriage through thyroid therapy, examining both partners rather than focusing solely on women.

Heart disease also links to hypothyroidism, as thyroid hormones control cholesterol levels and blood clotting. Thyroid deficiencies may contribute to atherosclerosis, increased blood pressure, and elevated stroke or heart attack risk. Contrary to past concerns, hypothyroidism itself, rather than thyroid treatment, appears to increase osteoporosis risk by retarding bone modeling and tissue repair.

Treatment Approaches

Current hypothyroidism treatment typically involves hormone replacement with T4-only medications like Synthroid, Levothroid, or Levoxyl. However, many practitioners question this approach’s effectiveness. Since T3 performs most thyroid work in the body, T4-only treatment may under-treat patients, particularly those with poor T4-to-T3 conversion.

Alternative treatments include T3 medications like Cytomel, compounded combinations of T3 and T4, or desiccated whole animal thyroid products like Armour, Nature-throid, and Westhroid. These natural preparations contain both T3 and T4, plus other potentially active thyroid compounds. Dr. Barnes observed that patients switching from synthetic to natural thyroid often experienced resolution of persistent symptoms like dry skin and fluid retention, suggesting the presence of additional beneficial thyroid factors.

Treatment Philosophy

The ultimate goal of thyroid treatment should be symptom relief and optimal function rather than simply normalizing blood test results. Thyroid hormone levels don’t reliably correlate with how patients feel; some individuals with “mild” laboratory abnormalities experience severe symptoms while others with significant test deviations feel fine. This disconnect emphasizes the importance of treating the patient, not just the numbers, and highlights why comprehensive evaluation including symptoms, temperature, and laboratory results provides the most complete picture of thyroid function.

The growing recognition of widespread subclinical hypothyroidism challenges conventional medical approaches and suggests that more sensitive diagnostic methods and individualized treatment strategies may be necessary to address this hidden epidemic effectively.

Download for the full article.